Return to Tiffany Collection

Shop from our selection of authentic used Return to Tiffany Jewelry. Our preowned Return to Tiffany Jewelry on sale is an iconic ensemble that encapsulates timeless elegance and sophistication. Our preowned Return to Tiffany jewelry on sale features bracelets, necklaces, and earrings adorned with the distinctive "Return to Tiffany" engraving, reflecting the brand's heritage and enduring charm. From the classic heart-shaped pendants to the elegant bracelets and charming keyrings, our used Return to Tiffany jewelry for sale represents a fusion of tradition and modernity. Crafted in sterling silver and often complemented by Tiffany Blue accents, the Return to Tiffany Collection embodies a sense of timeless beauty and chic simplicity. Embraced by jewelry aficionados and fashion enthusiasts alike, this collection signifies the brand's legacy and contemporary allure. Whether worn as a personal statement or given as a cherished gift, our authenticated Return to Tiffany jewelry on sale remains an embodiment of refined luxury and enduring style.

55 items

Tiffany Sterling Silver Titanium Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Charm Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$425
Tiffany Sterling Silver Rubedo 4mm Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Bead Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$395
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Earrings
Condition: Shows Wear
$225
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Oval Tag Choker Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$495
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return To Tiffany Cufflinks
Condition: Shows Wear
$275
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return to Tiffany Double Heart Tag Pendant Necklace Pink
Condition: Shows Wear
$195
Tiffany Sterling Silver 4mm Return To Tiffany Round Tag Bead Bracelet
Condition: Excellent
$225
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Diamond Small Return to Tiffany Double Heart Tag Pendant Necklace Blue
Condition: Shows Wear
$495
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$395
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return To Tiffany Color Splash Oval Tag Pendant Necklace Blue
Condition: Shows Wear
$250
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Pendant Bead Chain Necklace 34"
Condition: Shows Wear
$175
Tiffany 18K Yellow Gold Return to Tiffany Full Heart Ring 58 8.5
Condition: Excellent
$1,195
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Diamond Return to Tiffany Double Mini Heart Tag Pendant Necklace Pink
Condition: Shows Wear
$275
Tiffany 18K Yellow Gold Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Excellent
$1,195
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return to Tiffany Double Heart Tag Pendant Necklace Red
Condition: Shows Wear
$275
Tiffany Sterling Silver Mini Return to Tiffany Multi Heart Tag Charm Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$650
Tiffany 18K White Gold Diamond Return to Love Heart Tag Key Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$1,695
Tiffany 18K Rose Gold Diamond Return to Love Heart Tag Key Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$1,695
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Charm Pink
Condition: Excellent
$175
Tiffany Sterling Silver Large Return to Firenze Heart Tag Charm
Condition: Shows Wear
$250
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel LOVE YOU Heart Charm Red
Condition: Shows Wear
$225
Tiffany Sterling Silver 18K Rose Gold Return to Tiffany Love Bugs Ladybug Ring 47 4
Condition: Excellent
$475
Tiffany Sterling Silver Diamond Medium Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Toggle Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$625
Tiffany 18K Yellow Gold Return to Tiffany Mini Double Heart Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$1,050
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany X Beyonce Renaissance Round Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Giftable
$325
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Choker Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$550
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Oval Tag Choker Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$525
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Charm Pink
Condition: Excellent
$195
Tiffany Sterling Silver Diamond Small Return to Tiffany Heart Pendant Necklace
Condition: Excellent
$395
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Charm Bracelet Blue
Condition: Shows Wear
$425
Tiffany Sterling Silver Rubedo Mini Return To Tiffany Double Heart Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$225
Tiffany Sterling Silver 10mm Return To Tiffany Round Tag Bead Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$295
Tiffany Sterling Silver Titanium Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$250
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Round Charm Ring 50 5.5
Condition: Shows Wear
$225$215
Tiffany Sterling Silver Diamond Cultured Pearl Return to Tiffany Wrap Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$1,295$1,230
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany X Beyonce Renaissance Round Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$295$280
Tiffany Sterling Silver Mini Return to Tiffany Double Heart Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$225$215
Tiffany Sterling Silver 18K Rose Gold Return to Tiffany Love Bugs Butterfly Ring 47 4
Condition: Giftable
$450$425
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Round Charm Ring 50 5.5
Condition: Shows Wear
$225$215
Tiffany Sterling Silver Diamond Cultured Pearl Return to Tiffany Wrap Necklace
Condition: Excellent
$1,495$1,420
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return To Tiffany Lock Love Ring 46 3.75
Condition: Excellent
$325$310
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel 4mm Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Bead Bracelet Blue
Condition: Shows Wear
$275$260
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return to Tiffany Double Heart Tag Pendant Necklace Red
Condition: Shows Wear
$275$260
Tiffany Sterling Silver 4mm Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Bead Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$250$235
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Heart Signet Ring 47 4
Condition: Shows Wear
$295$280
Tiffany Sterling Silver 8mm Return To Tiffany Heart Tag Bead Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$325$290
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Etched Heart and Arrow Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Excellent
$295$265
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return to Tiffany Color Splash Heart Tag Bracelet Black
Condition: Shows Wear
$450$405
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Love Lock Bracelet
Condition: Shows Wear
$550$495
Tiffany Sterling Silver Enamel Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Charm Pink
Condition: Excellent
$225$200
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return To Tiffany Etched Heart and Arrow Tag Pendant Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$350$280
Tiffany Sterling Silver Leather Return to Tiffany Single Wrap Bracelet Cobalt Blue
Condition: Shows Wear
$375$300
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Love Heart Lock Charm
Condition: Excellent
$450$360
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return to Love Heart Lock Charm
Condition: Shows Wear
$395$295
Tiffany Sterling Silver Return To Tiffany Love Pendant Necklace
Condition: Shows Wear
$395$295

#FASHIONPHILE

a woman in white pants and a green sweater holding a blue Hermes Bolide

sippingmycosmo

A woman in jeans and an olive green blazer holding a pink Balenciaga Mini City Bag

marlizzlle

woman in a beige dress and sweater holding a Louis Vuitton Monogram Croissant Bag

caffeinequeenblog

a woman in a pink sleeveless top and jeans holding a Pink Hermes Birkin 25

pinkclassicchic

a woman in a yellow dress and yellow sweater holding a yellow Celine Triomphe bag

paulinehaydee

a woma in a light blue sweatshirt hold a brown Bottega Veneta Intrecciato Hobo bag

lindseyrem

a woman in black pants and a grey fur coat holding a black Chanel 19 bag

kelseyngross

a woman in a white top and black coat holding a Louis Vuitton Damier Ebene Speedy

jessiinsanfrancisco

a woman in a black tweed jacket wearing a black tweed Chanel Kelly

annabellefleur

a woman in a white long skirt and brown blazer holding a black Hermes Kelly bag

hauteaires

a man in a white button down long sleeve shirt and brown sweater vest wearing a brown Bottega Veneta Cassette

justinliv

a woman in a black skirt and coat holding a white Christian Dior Lady Dior bag

petitemarienyc